Issue #2
Prometheus in China
Techno-Optimism and Its Discontents
July—December 2022
In 2020, Chinese Communist Party general secretary Xi Jinping pledged to ‘transition to a green and low-carbon mode of development’, as well as to ‘peak the country’s CO2 emissions before 2030 and achieve carbon neutrality before 2060’. Xi’s pledge offered a tangible example of what has come to be known as the ecological civilisation (生态文明)—the idea of engineered harmony between humans and nature that was recently incorporated into the Constitution of the People’s Republic of China. But what kind of engineering is required for sustainable transitions at this scale and pace? Through which political concepts and technical practices could such a harmonious rebalancing of China’s resource-devouring development be envisioned and achieved?
This issue of the Made in China Journal addresses these questions by borrowing political theorist John Dryzek’s rereading of the Greek myth of Prometheus. Inspired by the story of a demigod who stole the technology of fire for the sole purpose of human advancement, Prometheanism describes an eco-modernist orientation that perceives the Earth as a resource whose utility is determined primarily by human needs and interests and whose environmental problems are overcome through continuous political and technological innovation. In contrast with other environmental perspectives, Prometheanism prioritises human interests and needs over those of ecosystems or the individual needs of other lifeforms. Through this framework, we asked our contributors to offer their takes on the following questions: To what extent can Xi’s dream of an ecological civilisation be understood in terms of techno-optimism and the anthropocentrism that characterise Prometheanism? What price is China paying in its effort to transition towards a heavily engineered ‘sustainable’ market utopia?
Table of Contents
Op-eds
Wulumuqi Road | Christopher ConneryBiopolitical Binaries (or How Not to Read the Chinese Protests) | Christian Sorace and Nicholas Loubere
The Great Entrenchment: An Unofficial Synopsis of ‘Twentieth Party Congress Spirit’ | Holly Snape
Lying Flat: Profiling the Tangping Attitude | Marine Brossard
Praising a Dead Dictator: How US Officials’ Visits to Taiwan Wade into Complex Historical Debates | Brian Hioe
Focus
Why China Cannot Decarbonise | Richard SmithSky River: Promethean Dreams of Optimising the Atmosphere | Emily T. Yeh
Rise into Dust: Governing Land and Weather Systems in Contemporary China | Jerry Zee
Prometheus Brings Water: Development and Fix-Fixing in China | Stevan Harrell
Manipulating Water in China | Michael Webber
Prometheus and the Fishpond | Sigrid Schmalzer
Situating the ‘Science’ Craze in China | Xinmin Liu
Geoengineering the Sublime | Jesse Rodenbiker
The Promethean Ant Forest | Giulia dal Maso
Speculative Landscapes, Promethean Mirages, and Eco-Poiesis | Corey Byrnes
Conversations
The Opium Business: A Conversation with Peter Thilly | Margherita Zanasi and Peter ThillyImperial Gateway: A Conversation with Seiji Shirane | Jeffrey Wasserstrom and Seiji Shirane
Foreign Banks and Global Finance in Modern China A Conversation with Ghassan Moazzin | Matthew Lowenstein and Ghassan Moazzin
Tiger, Tyrant, Bandit, Businessman: A Conversation with Brian DeMare | Brian DeMare and Ivan Franceschini
Poverty and Pacification: A Conversation with Dorothy J. Solinger | Jenny Chan and Dorothy J. Solinger
Dreadful Desires: A Conversation with Charlie Yi Zhang | Shui-yin Sharon Yam and Charlie Yi Zhang
Transtopia in the Sinophone Pacific: A Conversation with Howard Chiang | Shui-yin Sharon Yam and Howard Chiang